Tybee Island Real Estate | Tybee Island Historical Properties for Sale

Step into a piece of Tybee Island history with this versatile historic beach home located just a block and a half from beach access. Once owned by the Honorable Judge Oliver, who presided over the high profile murder trial of antique dealer Jim Williams, the case that inspired the book "Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil". This unique property blends character, history and coastal living. Currently configured as two separate living spaces, the home offers exceptional flexibility. The upper level features two bedrooms, one bath, a fully equipped kitchen, dining and living areas, a welcoming screened front porch, and a spacious rear deck. the ground level includes two bedrooms, two baths, a kitchenette, dining area and a private rear patio. An interior staircase, currently enclosed, can easily be reopened to restore the home to a spacious single family residence. Whether you're searching for a primary residence, vacation home or investment opportunity, this property offers endless possibilities. Live in one level while renting the other or enjoy the entire home for yourself. Current zoning allows rentals of 30 days or longer, providing excellent income potential. Additional features include two outdoor showers, parking for up to four vehicles and an unbeatable location within walking distance of the beach, restaurants & bars, IGA and shopping. This is a rare opportunity to own a home with remarkable history, flexible living options and an exceptional coastal location.

1105 Lovell Ave, Tybee Island

$598,000

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ SA359440 MLS

MAKE YOUR NEW HOME IN PARADISE ON THIS DOUBLE SIZED HOMESITE ON TYBEE ISLAND. FANTASTIC OPPORTUNITY FOR A BUILDER, DEVELOPER, OR SOMEONE WITH IMAGINATION DREAMING OF YOUR PERFECT HOME. THIS MAY BE ONE OF THE BEST LOCATIONS ON TYBEE NEAR THE MAIN BEACH AND MANY ACTIVITIES. THE 1930s VINTAGE COTTAGE IS IN ROUGH CONDITION AND WILL NEED MUCH ATTENTION, OR POSSIBLY A TEAR DOWN. THE SITE IS APPROXIMATELY 0.26 ACRE WITH FRONTAGE ON TWO STREETS. IT IS VERY LIKELY THAT IT COULD BE DIVIDED INTO TWO VERY DESIRABLE HOMESITES FOR 2 NEW BEACH HOME DEVELOPMENTS. THAT'S 2 PRIME BUILDING SITES FOR THE AMAZINGLY LOW PRICE OF $299,000 EACH. PUBLIC WATER & SEWER, CLOSE TO BEACH, RESTAURANTS, ENTERTAINMENT, SHOPS, PUBLIC PIER, BOAT RAMP, ETC. THE DWELLING IS IN POOR CONDITION AND MAY BE OF LITTLE VALUE, OR IT COULD BE THE ULTIMATE FIXER-UPPER. NOTE: THE DWELLING IS IN SAD CONDITION, NEEDING MUCH WORK. THE VALUE IS IN THIS FANTASTIC VALUABLE LAND AND UNIQUE LOCATION.

1606 2nd Ave, Tybee Island

$499,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ SA359756 MLS

Step into a piece of Tybee Island history with this charming 2BD/2BA, cottage just two blocks from the beach. Offering 920 square feet of thoughtfully maintained living space, this one-of-a-kind home blends timeless character with the laid-back coastal lifestyle that makes Tybee so special. Inside, you'll find original hardwood floors, beautiful shiplap walls, and floor-to-ceiling cabinetry in the kitchen that adds both charm and functionality. Outside, enjoy an oversized outdoor shower after a day at the beach, a spacious 150-square-foot storage shed for all your beach gear, and a covered carport perfect for golf cart and bike parking. Two driveways provides abundant off-street parking for guests, boats, golf carts, or multiple vehicles. This lovingly maintained cottage offers historic character, unbeatable walkability, and an authentic Tybee Island lifestyle. Don't miss your chance to own a well-preserved piece of Tybee history just steps from the sand.

1305 Lovell Ave, Tybee Island

$490,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ SA359159 MLS

Welcome to your own slice of Tybee paradise! This adorable 2-bedroom, 1.5-bath cottage (rumored to be a Sears kit cottage) is perfectly situated just two blocks from the beach, pier, restaurants, shopping, and everything that makes island living so special. Engineered wood flooring downstairs, hardwood upstairs, abundant natural light, and a warm, inviting atmosphere that instantly feels like home. Outside you can enjoy the deck, great for entertaining, private fenced backyard featuring an outdoor shower for rinsing off after a day at the beach, a charming potting shed for gardening enthusiasts, and a spacious storage shed for bikes, beach gear, and more. Originally purchased earlier this year, an unexpected situation has created an opportunity for the next fortunate buyer to enjoy this wonderful cottage much sooner than anticipated. It's a rare chance to own a move-in-ready Tybee home in an unbeatable location. For buyers seeking a turnkey getaway, most furnishings are available to convey with an acceptable offer, making it easy to start enjoying island life from day one.

1405 2nd Ave, Tybee Island

$895,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ SA357566 MLS

Rare coveted opportunity on the beachside of Butler Avenue with exceptional redevelopment potential! Just 200 steps from the sand and a short stroll to the pier, shops, restaurants, and nightlife, this commercially zoned property sits in one of Tybee Island's most desirable locations. The existing 4-bedroom, 2-bath cottage has been renovated and is currently operating with an active STVR license, providing immediate income potential from day one. Whether you're looking for a turnkey vacation rental, a beachside getaway, or your next development project, this property offers unmatched flexibility. With valuable C-1 Commercial zoning, the possibilities are endless. Build your dream coastal retreat with room for a pool, expand the existing footprint, or capitalize on the site's full development potential. Zoned to accommodate up to four large condominium units, each eligible for STVR licensing, this is a rare chance to create a premier income-producing asset just steps from the Atlantic Ocean.

10 17th Pl, Tybee Island

$729,000

6 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ SA355886 MLS

Rare opportunity to own an updated duplex on the beachside of Butler Avenue. Offering over 3,000 square feet, this property is configured as two separate units with outstanding income potential. The upper level features a fully furnished 3BR/2BA apartment currently operating as a successful vacation rental. Recently updated, the unit includes a sun porch, spacious living room, dining room, kitchen, laundry area, guest bath, two guest bedrooms, and a primary suite with en-suite bath and sitting room. The lower level has been reconfigured as a 3BR/1BA unit with a living room, kitchen, and storage area, offering excellent flexibility for long-term rental income, guest accommodations, or owner occupancy. Additional features include covered and uncovered patios and original 1920s beadboard details that add timeless coastal charm. Sold fully furnished and turn-key. Successfully operated as a vacation rental for the past 5 years. With current rental regulations, this property offers excellent potential to live in one unit while renting the other. STVR license does not transfer with the sale.

16 13th St, Tybee Island

$900,000

5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ SA355673 MLS

Welcome to 709 2nd Avenue, a true Tybee Island retreat set in one of the island’s most desirable locations between the beach and Back River. Full of coastal character, this spacious 5-bedroom, 4-bath classic island cottage offers the rare combination of charm, flexibility, outdoor living, and room to gather. Inside, you’ll find inviting living spaces, an updated kitchen with granite countertops and stainless appliances, comfortable bedrooms across both levels, and a large bonus room ideal for a second living area, media space, home office, or guest overflow. The layout gives everyone room to spread out while still keeping the home warm, connected, and easy to enjoy. Offered furnished, this home presents an exceptional opportunity to immediately begin enjoying the Tybee lifestyle. Outdoor living is where this property truly stands apart. Start the morning on the welcoming front porch, spend quiet afternoons on the oversized screened porch, then unwind in the private fenced backyard featuring a heated pool, patio space, and mature coastal landscaping that creates a secluded island retreat atmosphere. Just moments from the sand, the river, restaurants, shops, and Tybee’s laid-back coastal lifestyle, 709 2nd Avenue delivers the space, location, and authentic island feel that make this home truly special.

709 2nd Ave, Tybee Island

$595,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ SA355449 MLS

Timeless elegance of this beautiful preserve 1940 Florida Art Deco style home on Tybee Island. Located at 1508 Miller Avenue this one-of-a-kind property offers all of its original architectural detail, including soaring 9 foot ceilings, vintage accents, and the unmistakable charm that comes with thoughtful, meticulous care over generations. Set on a spacious lot and a half a rare find on Tybee, the home provides ample outdoor space for gardens, pool, entertaining, or future expansion. Just a short stroll away, enjoy the convenience of the sunsets on the back river, boat ramp, or explore the vibrant, dining and shopping scene on the bustling south-end of the island. Whether you’re looking for a full-time residence, a Coastal getaway, or a piece of Tybee‘s history, this property offers, unmatched character and location. Don’t miss the opportunity to own a true Tybee Jim with both heart and Heritage..

1508 Miller, Tybee Island

$1,175,000

6 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ SA354232 MLS

Welcome to the Blue Pearl at 1102 Lovell Avenue, a spacious six-bedroom, five-bath historic Tybee Island beach house located just one block from the beach. Built circa 1932, this distinctive mid-island home combines authentic coastal character, generous living space, and a flexible floor plan ideal for a primary residence, second home, vacation home, or multi-generational living. The main living level features three bedrooms and three full bathrooms, high ceilings, original heart pine floors, built-in heart pine corner cupboards, tongue-and-groove pine paneling, and timeless architectural details. The updated kitchen offers quartz countertops, a gas cooktop, wine refrigerator, and an impressive 10-foot peninsula with bar seating. The light filled primary suite includes double vanities, a classic clawfoot tub, and a separate shower. A spacious 27-by-12-foot screened porch extends the living area and provides an inviting place to gather, dine, or enjoy Tybee’s coastal breezes. The lower level adds two private guest areas, each with its own kitchen, entrance, and outdoor space. Interior access and a shared den connect the home’s living areas, allowing it to function as one cohesive six-bedroom residence while providing privacy for extended family, adult children, long-term guests, or a dedicated home office. Additional features include six off-street parking spaces plus a one-car garage, a valuable amenity for a six-bedroom Tybee Island home. Conveniently located near the beach, Memorial Park, the YMCA, library, restaurants, and shopping, the Blue Pearl offers a rare opportunity to own a spacious and versatile historic home in the heart of Tybee Island.

1102 Lovell Ave, Tybee Island

$975,000

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ SA351529 MLS

Builders and investors !. .17 acres just a few lots from the beach on Tybee Island, this exceptional C-1 zoned parcel offers a rare opportunity to build in one of Georgia’s most sought-after coastal destinations. Whether you’re envisioning a boutique investment property, vacation rentals, or a mixed-use coastal retreat, the possibilities here are wide open on this one. Located in the heart of Tybee Island, this lot places you within easy walking distance to the beach, local restaurants, shops, and the vibrant island lifestyle that draws visitors year-round. With C-1 zoning, investors may have the potential to develop up to a four-unit property (buyer to verify), making this an ideal site for income-producing vacation rentals or a unique coastal development.

17 Silver Ave, Tybee Island

$1,100,000

5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ SA351366 MLS

Eclectic, beachy, and full of Tybee charm, 1017 Lovell Avenue is a truly special mid-island retreat just moments from the beach. Set on a large lot just two blocks from the 11th Street beach walkover, this vintage two-story cottage blends relaxed coastal style with resort-like outdoor living, featuring a family-sized inground pool, an inviting screened porch, and a one-of-a-kind tiki hut that creates the ultimate backyard escape. Inside, the home is filled with personality and great design choices throughout, offering a fun, curated aesthetic that feels both laid-back and memorable. The main level flows beautifully for everyday living and entertaining, while the upper level opens to a deck overlooking the pool. The fully fenced yard offers exceptional privacy and flexibility, with plenty of room to lounge, gather, and enjoy the island lifestyle. Located in the heart of Tybee, just a short walk or bike ride to restaurants, shops, Memorial Park, and the beach, this home has been a highly successful vacation rental grossing in excess of $100,000 yearly. Showings will be subject to availability.

1017 Lovell Ave, Tybee Island

$639,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ SA351268 MLS

Beautiful home just two blocks from the beach! All kinds of possibilities with a very unique 100+ year old Tybee Cottage. Wrap around porch, deck, courtyard and plenty of space to enclose. Plenty of parking. 2 bedrooms, 2 full baths and large entertainment area with drive-in garage and covered bonus area.

1115 2nd Ave, Tybee Island

$774,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ SA350990 MLS

Mermaid's Tale is a family gathering home with room for all of your friends and relatives. Four bedrooms with two master suites, Open living room with charming fireplace, dining room and kitchen area. 3 bedrooms and a bunk room. Awesome outdoor space with several patios and a rocking chair porch. Lots of parking. Just a few blocks to the beach and walking distances to restaurants and shopping. Time to move to the BEACH!!

705 2nd Ave, Tybee Island

$574,500

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ SA350289 MLS

Welcome to Parrot Head Cottage at 912 Jones Avenue—a beautifully maintained Key West–style home blending classic brick architecture, graceful archways, and bright coastal charm. Inside, the home offers a warm, refined feel with abundant natural light and a layout designed for relaxed island living. The inviting living room flows into a spacious kitchen perfect for Lowcountry cooking, offering generous counter space, storage, and an easy gathering area. The recently updated bathrooms add fresh style and comfort. Both main bedrooms offer a serene retreat with soft natural light. A cozy side porch with a relaxing swing provides the perfect spot to unwind and enjoy gentle island breezes. Upstairs, the spacious bonus room serves as the third bedroom and offers versatile use as a guest suite, office, or studio. Outside, the yard provides room for a boat, golf cart, cookouts, or creating a beautiful outdoor living area. The desirable mid-island location places you moments from the back river, the beach, and local restaurants—offering the ideal blend of convenience, charm, and true Tybee living.

912 Jones Ave, Tybee Island

$2,200,000

9 Beds ⋅ 10 Baths ⋅ SA350242 MLS ⋅ Tybee Island B&B BLDG.

Presenting a rare opportunity to acquire a landmark hospitality property on Tybee Island. Originally built in 1902 as a day hospital for Fort Screven, this distinguished 9BR/9.5BA bed & breakfast encompasses 5,283 square feet on a beautifully treed .33-acre parcel just steps from North Beach and Jaycee Park. Rich in character yet thoughtfully updated, the inn offers expansive gathering spaces, an inviting dining room, a wood-burning fireplace, and a commercial-grade kitchen designed for seamless service. The landscaped front courtyard, complete with fountain, hardscape, fencing, and mature oaks, along with a gracious covered porch and gazebo, creates an unforgettable guest arrival experience. Offered turnkey with an established wedding and event component, ample parking (11 spaces), and an assumable SBA loan option, this is a rare legacy investment where history, hospitality, and coastal sophistication converge.

24 Van Horne Ave, Tybee Island

$2,100,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ SA348866 MLS

Introducing a once-in-a-generation opportunity on Tybee Island. 4 10th Terrace represents the largest directly oceanfront parcel currently available — an extraordinary stretch of approximately 317 feet deep by 65 feet wide set directly on the Atlantic Ocean in a premier mid-island location. A private, dedicated boardwalk carries you over Tybee’s rolling dunes straight to the sand, offering unmatched privacy and an experience rarely found on the island. Whether envisioned as a legacy beachfront estate or a transformative development opportunity, the scale and positioning of this property are simply irreplaceable. The expansive lot presents the potential to partition into multiple parcels or create a singular, world-class oceanfront compound. The existing historic cottage, built circa 1930 and among the oldest homes on Tybee, offers timeless coastal charm with a welcoming screened porch perfectly positioned to capture ocean breezes. The main residence features three bedrooms, a ground-level office or flex space, and a separate guest suite — ideal for immediate enjoyment, rental income, or as a foundation for future vision. Properties of this magnitude, history, and beachfront frontage rarely come to market. An exceptional setting. Unmatched potential. One of Tybee Island’s most compelling oceanfront offerings.

4 10th Ter, Tybee Island

$975,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ SA336623 MLS

**Your Tybee Island Dream Awaits** Just steps from Tybee Island's stunning South End beaches, this rare coastal gem is a true turnkey opportunity, complete with a transferable STVR certificate ready to go from day one. The upper unit sleeps six across two bright bedrooms, two full baths, and a charming sleeping nook, all wrapped in warm hardwood floors and glowing natural light that captures the essence of classic beach cottage living.cDownstairs, the lower level has been transformed into the ultimate entertainment space. With sleek epoxy floors and an open industrial-chic layout, this level is ready to become a game room, home theater, or lively lounge — the kind of amenity that sets a rental apart and commands premium rates. Outside, ample space and easy parking complement the property's unbeatable position in Tybee's most coveted neighborhood — close to the beach, local dining, and island shops, yet tucked away for peaceful coastal living. This is the rare property that delivers both a dream lifestyle and a smart investment in one sun-soaked package.The house sits half of a block from the beach and approximately four feet below sea level. ***The lower level floods during bad rain events. The owner has spent significant money trying to reduce the issue, but the practical reality is that the lower level will get water during severe weather. The sell price is discounted accordingly. *** Click Reel for Designated Website and Video

9 Ts Chu Ter, Tybee Island

$1,225,000

5 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ SA336270 MLS

Great opportunity to own a classic Tybee cottage beach side of Butler that has been updated over the years. Large screened porches upstairs and down. Plenty of room under the house for hanging out and playing a game of ping pong. Kitchens are upstairs and down allowing for large families to spread out and have their own space. 2 bedrooms upstairs and 3 bedrooms down. The outside shower is located next to the downstairs entrance for rinsing off after a great day on the beach. Interior and exterior stairs allow for the house to be used as 1 big house, or split for 2 families. And what a great location for the world famous Beach Bum parade! This is a great opportunity to finally own a really cool old cottage on Tybee large enough for the whole family to come visit.

606 Butler Ave, Tybee Island

$900,000

5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ SA337109 MLS

Beachside 5BR/2.5BA 1564 sqft Single Family Home on 10th Terrace on a Lot & a Half! Highly Desirable Mid Island Location Beachside of Butler. The “Mullet Manor” is just 3 Homes to the Beach w/Access to Nearby Beach Crosswalk! Two Open & Bright Living Areas w/Tall Tongue&Groove Ceilings + an Additional Back Entrance. Kitchen w/Updated LVP Flooring, Updated White Shaker Cabinets, White Tile Backsplash & Granite Countertops. Dining Area Off of Kitchen. Main Level Split Floor Plan w/Primary Bedroom + 2 Additional Bedrooms & 1.5 Bathrooms. Full Bath Features Shower/Tub Combo, Linen Shelving, Walk-In Shower & Updated Double Vanity w/Granite Countertops. Half Bath Has Potential to Become a Full Bath! Downstairs Features 2 More Bedrooms, Full Bathroom & Game Room. Outdoor Shower. Parking Available on Both Sides of Home. Room to Add a Pool! Walking Distance to Tybee Market IGA, Memorial Park, YMCA, Shops & Local Restaurants: Treylor Park Beach Party, Mi Vida, The Breakfast Club & Stingray’s Seafood! ** City Council is considering an STVR ordinance change to allow for new owners to apply for an STVR certificate on homes that currently have one. Expected vote date by cc is August 27th.**

10 10th Ter, Tybee Island

Tybee Island Historical Properties for Sale

Newest Tybee Island Historical Properties for Sale